Scottie Pippen VS Dennis Rodman?

It is hard to compare the two, Pippen would probably be my choice to guard all of the guards you listed. However if they were big men I would choose Rodman. You forgot to mention that Rodman was the best rebounder on the team for the Bulls and was much more of a post player then Pippen was. Since they didn't really have the same style of play I think it is really hard to compare the two or to choose one. It would depend on what potion I needed to fill on who I choose.